top of page

Theology Thursday: Thomas Aquinas and the Argument from Motion

2 days ago
3 min read

If Everything Changes, What Makes Change Possible?

Have you ever stopped to consider why anything changes?

A seed becomes a tree. Water becomes ice. A child grows into an adult. Everywhere we look, the world is constantly changing.

But have you ever wondered what makes change possible in the first place?

In the 13th century, Christian theologian and philosopher Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) explored this question in his famous work, Summa Theologiae.

Aquinas developed five philosophical arguments, commonly called the Five Ways, for demonstrating God's existence. His first argument, known as the Argument from Motion, begins with a simple observation:

Things change.

But Aquinas believed that this ordinary observation reveals something extraordinary about the nature of reality.


What Did Aquinas Mean by Motion?

When we hear the word motion, we usually think of something physically moving, such as a car driving down the road or the Earth revolving around the sun.

However, Aquinas was using the word in a much broader philosophical sense.

For Aquinas, motion meant change—the actualization of a potential.

Consider a piece of wood.

The wood has the potential to become hot, but it is not necessarily hot already. When fire heats the wood, that potential becomes actual.

The fire, already hot, causes the wood to become hot.

Aquinas distinguished between two important concepts:

Potentiality: What something is capable of becoming.

Actuality: What something already is.

Something cannot bring itself from potentiality to actuality in the same respect and at the same time. Change requires something already actual to bring about that change.


The Unmoved Mover

This leads us to Aquinas' central question:

If changing things require something already actual to cause their change, can this dependence continue infinitely?

Aquinas argued that an essentially ordered series of causes cannot continue infinitely without a foundational source.

Imagine a hand moving a stick that moves a stone.

The stick moves the stone because the hand is moving the stick. The stick does not possess the independent power to produce that movement in this example.

Aquinas reasoned that if every source of motion depended entirely on another, with no ultimate source, the series would have no foundational explanation for its activity.

Therefore, he concluded that there must be a first source of motion that is not itself moved by another.

He called this the Unmoved Mover.

And Aquinas identified this ultimate source with God.

Importantly, Aquinas was not simply arguing that the universe must have begun at some point in the distant past.

His argument concerns the dependence of change on causes operating here and now.


What Does This Tell Us About God?

Aquinas' argument challenges us to think beyond the created world.

God is not simply the strongest or most powerful being among other beings.

In classical Christian theology, God is the eternal, self-existent Creator upon whom everything else depends.

Unlike creation, God does not need to be changed, completed, or brought into existence by something else.

Aquinas' broader theology describes God as pure actuality—without unrealized potentiality.

This understanding also helps explain why Christians describe God as immutable, meaning that His divine nature does not change.


What Does Scripture Say?

Although Aquinas developed his argument through philosophy, Scripture also teaches that creation depends upon God.

For ‘In him we live and move and have our being.’ — Acts 17:28 (ESV)
And he is before all things, and in him all things hold together. — Colossians 1:17 (ESV)

These passages are not themselves presentations of Aquinas' philosophical argument. Rather, they express a biblical truth that complements his theological understanding: creation is dependent upon God.


Why Does This Matter for Our Faith?

We sometimes think of God as someone who created the universe and then stepped back to watch everything unfold.

But classical Christian theology presents a much deeper picture.

God is not merely responsible for creation's beginning. All creation continues to depend upon Him.

Every breath, every heartbeat, and every moment of our existence reminds us that we are not self-sufficient.

And here is something even more remarkable:

The God upon whom all creation depends desires to be known by the people He created.

Through Jesus Christ, we are invited into a relationship with the eternal God who needs nothing from us, yet graciously makes Himself known.


Theology Thursday Reflection

Aquinas invites us to look beyond the changes we observe and consider their ultimate explanation.

The next time you see a seed growing, a river flowing, or the seasons changing, consider this question:

If everything around us depends on something else, what is the ultimate foundation of its existence and activity?

The Argument from Motion is one philosophical approach to that question. While philosophers continue to debate its premises and conclusions, it remains an influential contribution to Christian thought.

At Got Theology? Ministries, we believe that studying theology should do more than expand our knowledge.

It should deepen our wonder at who God is.


Got Theology? Ministries

Because knowing God changes everything.

Visit gottheology.org for more biblical teaching and theological resources.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Lesson 3: Spiritual Maturity

Hebrews challenges believers to move beyond spiritual infancy into discernment, obedience, and intentional growth.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page